Virtual Currency-Based Sale Agreement an Invalid Contract, Chinese Court Rules

A virtual currency cannot be circulated in the market as a currency, therefore a vehicle sale contract wherein parties agreed that the buyer would pay with a privately issued digital currency is invalid, a Chinese court has ruled. The court asserts that a virtual currency does not have the same legal status as national fiat currency.

Not Protected by Law

A Chinese court has ruled that a vehicle sale contract, in which the parties agreed that the buyer would pay via a virtual currency, violated mandatory provisions of laws and administrative regulations and is therefore invalid. According to the court, a virtual currency “cannot be circulated in the market as [a] currency.”

As stated in one Chinese language report, the Shanghai court’s ruling was made after an aggrieved vehicle buyer sought the court’s intervention. According to the report, a buyer only identified as Huang had signed a sale agreement with Shanghai Automobile Service Co Ltd in May 2019.

As part of the agreement, Huang would purchase an Audi sports vehicle “with Yurimi as a currency payment.” Upon receipt of 1,281 units of the Yurimi virtual currency, the seller was, as per the agreement, expected to deliver the vehicle. However, after the seller failed to deliver, Huang sought redress via the Shanghai Fengxian Court.

Arguing his case before the court, Huang insisted that Yurimi is a virtual commodity that could be exchanged for goods thus it “does not violate the prohibitive provisions and should be valid.” However, in its counterargument, Shanghai Automobile Service Co Ltd insisted the sale agreement is an invalid contract and therefore should not be protected by the law.

Virtual Currencies Lack ‘Legal Compensation and Compulsion’

In its ruling, the Shanghai Fengxian Court said the country’s token issuance and finance regulations that were implemented in 2017 stipulate that tokens or “virtual currency” used in the financing of token issuance, are not issued by monetary authorities hence they lack attributes such as “legal compensation and compulsion.”

In addition, such virtual currency does not have the same legal status as national fiat currency, the report said. This, therefore, means they “cannot and should not be circulated in the market as a currency.”

According to the report, Huang, who was not pleased with the decision, went on to file an appeal with Shanghai No. 1 Intermediate Court. However, after reviewing Huang’s appeal, the superior court still ruled to uphold the lower court’s decision.

What are your thoughts on this story? Let us know what you think in the comments section below.

Earning Passive Income With Crypto

Related Posts

400+ Crypto Advertisements Violate Guidelines in India — ‘Some Influencers Talk About Crypto Without Understanding It’

The Advertising Standards Council of India (ASCI) has reportedly revealed that more than 400 crypto ads violated its guidelines so far this year. The majority of complaints…

Investment: How To Calculate The Attractiveness of a Cryptocurrency

Investment: Asset manager, financier, and cryptocurrency teacher Alexander Alexandrovich Ryabinin says the investment attractiveness of digital assets can be determined by analyzing inflationary and deflationary processes. The…

Rich Dad Poor Dad’s Robert Kiyosaki Says He’s Waiting for Bitcoin to Test $1,100 to Buy More

The famous author of the best-selling book Rich Dad Poor Dad, Robert Kiyosaki, says he’s waiting for the price of bitcoin to test $1,100. He added that…

This is the Future of the Liquid Staking, Based on the Past

Staking and the future: The liquid staking industry is at a turning point, says Simon Furlong, the Co-Founder of Geode Finance. The various opportunities across DeFi and cryptocurrency…

Book by Nigerian Author Reminds New Adopters Why Bitcoin Was Created

Nigerian author and crypto advocate Nathaniel Luz has said his recently published book represents his attempt to remind people of the initial reason why bitcoin was created….

Voyager Digital Issued Notice of 3AC’s Loan Default; Here’s What Might Be Next

Crypto hedge fund Three Arrows Capital (3AC) has defaulted on an estimated loan of $670 million, as per the market update by Voyager Digital. In a release dated June…